You might think choosing between a Monstera and Fiddle Leaf Fig comes down to aesthetics, but there’s more to reflect upon than their Instagram-worthy appearances. These trendy houseplants differ considerably in their care requirements, with Monsteras tolerating various light conditions and occasional neglect, while Fiddle Leaf Figs demand precise attention to thrive. Before you commit to either plant, you’ll want to understand how their unique needs align with your space and schedule.
Contents
A Tale of Two Trending Houseplants
While both plants have taken social media by storm in recent years, Monstera deliciosa and Fiddle Leaf Fig (Ficus lyrata) represent two distinct paths to becoming houseplant royalty.
You’ll find Monsteras climbing walls in tropical regions, reaching heights of 60 feet or more, while Fiddle Leaf Figs grow as understory trees in West African rainforests. In your home, these architectural beauties typically max out at 6-10 feet tall.
Their popularity isn’t just about looks – you’re getting two different maintenance experiences. Monsteras forgive occasional neglect, but Fiddle Leaf Figs demand consistent care and precise conditions to thrive.
Light Requirements and Placement
Although both plants require bright, indirect light to thrive, they differ significantly in their light tolerance and ideal placement. Your Monstera will adapt to medium-light conditions, though growth may slow, while Fiddle Leaf Figs are exceptionally less forgiving.
Position your Monstera 3-6 feet from east or north-facing windows, where it’ll receive filtered morning light. For Fiddle Leaf Figs, choose a spot 2-3 feet from bright south or west-facing windows, but shield them from direct afternoon sun to prevent leaf burn.
You’ll know the light’s too intense if you notice brown spots on your Fiddle Leaf Fig, while your Monstera will signal insufficient light through slower leaf splitting and smaller foliage.
Watering Needs and Humidity Preferences
Despite their shared tropical origins, these popular houseplants have distinct watering requirements. Your Monstera prefers its soil to dry out partially between waterings, typically needing water every 7-10 days, while Fiddle Leaf Figs need consistent moisture with waterings every 5-7 days.
When it comes to humidity, both plants thrive in levels between 60-80%. You’ll want to mist your Fiddle Leaf Fig twice weekly, whereas Monsteras are more forgiving. If your home’s humidity drops below 40%, consider using a humidifier or placing either plant on a pebble tray filled with water for added moisture.
Growth Patterns and Maintenance
Since both plants showcase dramatically different growth habits, you’ll need to adapt your maintenance approach accordingly. Your Monstera will climb and spread horizontally, requiring a moss pole or trellis for support, while your Fiddle Leaf Fig grows upward in a tree-like pattern.
You’ll notice your Monstera’s growth spurts during spring and summer, with new leaves unfurling every 4-6 weeks. The Fiddle Leaf Fig, however, grows more slowly, producing new leaves every 6-8 weeks when conditions are ideal.
To maintain shape, prune your Monstera’s wayward vines annually, and trim your Fiddle Leaf Fig when it reaches your desired height, typically 6-8 feet indoors.
Common Problems and Solutions
While both plants can face similar issues, they’ll exhibit distinct warning signs when struggling. Monsteras typically show brown spots from overwatering, while fiddle leaf figs drop leaves when stressed. You’ll notice yellow leaves on your monstera if it’s getting too much sun, whereas fiddle leaf figs develop brown spots in direct sunlight.
Root rot affects both species but manifests differently. In monsteras, stems become mushy and black, requiring immediate pruning and repotting. Fiddle leaf figs show signs through drooping leaves and a foul soil smell. For both plants, guarantee proper drainage and avoid overwatering by checking soil moisture with your finger before adding water.
Cost and Availability Comparison
The price gap between these two popular houseplants can be substantial. You’ll typically find Monstera deliciosa ranging from $15 to $50, while Fiddle Leaf Figs often command $50 to $200, depending on size and maturity.
Monsteras are widely available at most garden centers, big-box stores, and local nurseries year-round. You won’t have trouble finding them in 4-inch to 10-inch pots. Fiddle Leaf Figs, however, can be trickier to source and often require specialty plant shops or online retailers.
When buying online, you’ll pay 20-30% more for shipping due to the Fiddle Leaf’s sensitive nature and need for careful packaging.
Making the Final Decision: Space and Lifestyle Considerations
Before selecting between these striking tropical plants, you’ll need to assess your living space and daily routine. Monsteras adapt well to smaller spaces and can thrive in 6-foot-wide areas, while Fiddle Leaf Figs require at least 8 feet of ceiling height and 4 feet of floor space.
Consider your schedule, too. If you travel frequently, choose a Monstera – they’re more forgiving when waterings are irregular. Fiddle Leaf Figs demand consistent care and precise watering every 7-10 days. Your light conditions matter as well: Monsteras tolerate medium light, while Fiddles need bright, indirect sunlight for 6-8 hours daily.